First Kill

Katie Dunn

Director

Mike McFarland

Timothy Krajcir

Todd Jenkins

Bruce Chesser

April Hartman

Scissors Victim

Martha Harms

Brenda Parsh

Leticia Magaña

Mary Parsh

Rachel Dee

Donna Lauria

Maeghan Albach

Karen Chesser-Parsh

Susana Gibb

Gwen Thoma

Kerry McCormick

EMT

Sean McGraw

Floyd Parsh

Tom Costello Jr.

Interrogation Detective

Joshua Gage

Timothy Krajcir (5)

Allison Victoria-Wolfe

Krajcir's Wife

Dean Gosdin

Detective Jimmy Smith

Aaron M. Sanchez

Lauria Brother #1

Kris Mohandie

Self - Clinic and Forensic Psychologist

Joseph Coffey

Self - Detective, NYPD

Sam Swanson

Robert Violante

Mary Boylan

Writer

Lorraine DiRienzo

Writer

Ed Hersh

Writer

Paul Spillenger

Writer